The Crittenden Compromise

Attempt to Save Slavery

Introduction

Juneteenth is a celebration of freedom, marking the day when the last enslaved African Americans in Texas learned of their emancipation. But the road to freedom was long and filled with political battles, compromises, and resistance from those who wanted to keep slavery alive. One of the last major attempts to preserve slavery in the United States was the Crittenden Compromise, a proposal introduced just before the Civil War. Understanding this compromise helps us see how close the country came to permanently protecting slavery—and why its failure was a crucial step toward justice.

The Fight Over Slavery and Citizenship

Juneteenth marks a major turning point in American history. Around the time of Juneteenth and the end of slavery in the southern United States, about 250,000 of the 4 million enslaved people in America were freed. The passage of the 13th Amendment soon followed, officially ending slavery and moving the United States Constitution a little closer to its promise that "all men are created equal."

The 14th and 15th Amendments continued this progress. Former slaves, once counted as only three-fifths of a person under the Constitution, were now recognized as full American citizens. These amendments promised equal protection under the law and voting rights, at least in theory. Although struggles continued, these changes represented a giant leap toward true citizenship and human rights for African Americans.

Why Juneteenth and July 4th Matter Together

Before Juneteenth, the Fourth of July did not fully apply to all Americans. July 4th celebrated the nation's independence, but enslaved African Americans were not included in that freedom. Today, because of Juneteenth, Independence Day can truly be seen as a celebration for all citizens. While July 4th represents the birth of a free nation, Juneteenth celebrates the freedom and independence of a people—Africans and African Americans—within that nation.

The Crittenden Compromise: A Desperate Attempt to Keep Slavery

As early as Abraham Lincoln’s presidential campaign, debates about how to handle slavery were heating up. Both anti-slavery and pro-slavery groups wrestled with how the nation should move forward. During this time, U.S. Senator John Crittenden of Kentucky introduced a proposal called the Crittenden Compromise, aiming to settle the growing divide between the North and South.

Even though many of the original Constitutional delegates were slaveholders, the Constitution never directly mentioned slavery. Leaders knew slavery was a major part of the American economy, but few wanted to confront it head-on—not even Lincoln, who was campaigning for the highest office. Instead, there were several efforts to "compromise," including proposals that would have officially written slavery into the Constitution itself.

Turning Back the Clock to Protect Slavery

The Crittenden Compromise tried to roll back time. It sought to bring back the old Missouri Compromise boundaries of 1820, which limited where slavery could exist. Additionally, it proposed a new constitutional amendment that would permanently protect slavery from any future federal interference. Essentially, it tried to guarantee slavery’s survival forever.

The founding fathers may have avoided mentioning slavery in the Constitution because it clashed with the ideas of liberty and freedom that the document was built upon. However, over the years, political leaders from both major parties—Democrats and Republicans—continued to avoid fully addressing the injustice of slavery. This political avoidance lasted right up until the outbreak of the Civil War.

The Crittenden Compromise’s Failure and the Road to Freedom

The Crittenden Compromise serves as a reminder that, even as the nation inched toward ending slavery, there were powerful efforts to preserve it. Just before slavery's collapse, politicians were still trying to embed it into the nation's highest law. Thanks to the courage of those who fought for freedom—and the eventual failure of compromises like Crittenden’s—America took vital steps toward justice, equality, and true independence for all its people.

Conclusion: The Fight for True Freedom Continues

The failure of the Crittenden Compromise was a major turning point in American history. If it had passed, slavery might have lasted much longer—perhaps even permanently. But its defeat helped pave the way for the Civil War, the Emancipation Proclamation, and ultimately, the 13th, 14th, and 15th Amendments. Juneteenth is a reminder that freedom was never freely given—it had to be fought for. Understanding the political battles of the past, like the Crittenden Compromise, helps us appreciate the significance of Juneteenth and reminds us that the fight for justice and equality is ongoing.

What Are Your Thoughts?

The Crittenden Compromise reminds us of how fragile progress toward freedom can be, and how vital it is to learn from history. What are your thoughts on this failed attempt to preserve slavery and its role in shaping the future of the United States? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

🔗 Join the Conversation: If you found this post insightful, share it with friends, family, or anyone who might want to learn more about the history behind Juneteenth and the ongoing journey toward freedom and equality.